The Press Council of India's guidelines on reporting in conflict zones have recommended that governments not invoke stringent laws such as the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, the National Security Act or sedition against journalists for their reports, a suggestion on which council chairperson Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai dissented. The guidelines, along with her dissent, were adopted by the council on September 27, 2024, and incorporated in the 2026 edition of the PCI's Norms of Journalistic Conduct, released on October 16, according to HT, which reviewed the 130-page document. PCI guidelines are advisory in nature, and the body's prerogative extends only to print news publishers.
The first recommendation advised governments to either lodge complaints against journalists with the PCI or take action under media-related laws rather than booking them under harsh provisions such as treason, the National Security Act and UAPA. "Disagreement with the government or objection to any decision of the government should not be considered treason or a threat to national security. The PCI should be informed as soon as possible about the arrest of any journalist," the guidelines said.
Justice Desai disagreed with the provision, arguing that the PCI could not require state governments to send their complaints to it, nor decide whether a particular complaint should be filed. "The complainant has to approach the investigating agency directly," she said. She instead said such arrests should be made with due care and circumspection and that there should "be strong compelling and prima facie unimpeachable grounds" for them. "It must be remembered that every disagreement with the Government does not amount to treason or threat to national security," she said.
The second recommendation she flagged spoke against unnecessarily pressuring journalists to reveal their sources and called for respect for the Supreme Court's views in this regard. In her dissent note, Justice Desai said it was too vague and recommended: "Journalists should not be unnecessarily compelled to reveal the source of news. However cases which attract reasonable restrictions enumerated in Article 19(2) of the Constitution stand on a different footing and may require different treatment. In such cases source may have to be disclosed."
