Justice N. Anand Venkatesh of the Madras High Court has said there is no mechanism to ensure that an arbitrator is fit for the role, and no way to hold one accountable for failing to do the job. Speaking on Tuesday at an online dispute resolution summit on technology and institutional arbitration organised by Presolv360 in Chennai, he said arbitration demands a completely different mindset and that even High Court and Supreme Court judges would need training in it. He noted that while judges from the district judiciary are subject to a mechanism, and High Court judges can at least be transferred or have a portfolio taken away, arbitrators have no such oversight. An intelligent but corrupt arbitrator, he said, would leave parties with no way to challenge the outcome, and he called for a system under which courts accredit arbitrators, along with quality arbitrators possessing integrity, honesty and the ability to grasp the dispute.

Former Punjab and Haryana High Court judge K. Kannan said all stakeholders, including mediation institutions and lawyers, must develop a common framework to handle a high volume of disputes. He stressed the need for standardised protocols covering referrals, mediation, arbitration, settlement, documentation, quality assurance and grievance redressal.

Former Union Law Secretary T.K. Viswanathan, who recalled drafting several legislations, suggested that every Ministry present data to Parliament during its annual budget on how a law has been working in practice, and that funds be allocated for law schools to conduct studies on laws in action. He said law reform today depends on accidents of litigation and is not scientific, and asked how the success of an Act could be judged without data. He added that the Information Technology Act, 2000 now needs revision because of Artificial Intelligence, which he said was posing great problems.