Chief Justice of India Surya Kant said on Saturday that banning generative artificial intelligence tools would be neither practicable nor wise, and advocated clear rules and responsible use of the technology instead of a blanket prohibition. Addressing the first annual international conference of the Commonwealth Legal Education Association in Hyderabad, he cautioned that AI was fundamentally changing legal education, research and professional work, but stressed that technological assistance could not replace independent reasoning, verification and accountability.
The CJI said the question was no longer whether students would use these tools, but whether the work they submit still reflects their own reasoning and understanding of the law. He said banning AI tools would only drive their use underground, where institutions would have little opportunity to guide or examine it, and cited the Supreme Court of Singapore, which permits court users to employ generative AI while holding them fully responsible for what they file.
Warning that a fluent answer was not necessarily an accurate one, Justice Kant said such tools could generate fabricated judicial authorities, omit crucial qualifications in summarising judgments or produce incomplete comparative analyses. He said an AI system cannot be credited as an author because it cannot be held responsible for the work, and stressed that researchers must verify every authority against its primary source and disclose material AI assistance. He also cautioned against feeding confidential information into external AI platforms and urged universities, supervisors and publishers to frame clear guidance on AI use in research.
Beyond technology, the CJI called for legal education to move away from excessive dependence on theoretical instruction, with practical learning informing the teaching of core subjects. He also sought a compulsory minimum period of legal aid work for every law student before graduation, with additional academic credits for those who did more than the prescribed requirement.
