The Supreme Court on Monday stayed the shifting of books from the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) until Friday and directed that the collection of nearly 8.5 lakh books not be moved in the meantime, LiveLaw reported. Hearing the matter, a two-judge bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva expressed concern over the handling of the books, with Justice Kumar accusing the Centre of what appeared to be an ad hoc approach towards preserving the library's heritage. The court observed, according to the report: "You are just in a hurry to get done with this. What are you planning to do with these books? There seems to be an ad hoc approach. You are not bothered about… this is some heritage. Basically, a heritage for us dating back to 1702. If you don't want them, give them to some other country that will value them...Show some respect to these books; two lakh books thrown to the wind."
The hearing follows the apex court's suo motu cognisance of the lack of space allotted to the CSL under the Central Vista plan. In October, the court sought an affidavit detailing the space allotted to the library and its layout. The court's intervention was sought on 3 October after reports suggested the library, currently located in Shastri Bhawan, could face relocation in view of the proposed demolition of the building as part of the redevelopment plan. The Indian Express reported in October that the CSL, spread across four floors, was facing uncertainty as the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) had allotted it only two rooms in the Kartavya Bhawan-2 complex. The MoHUA had directed all ministries to vacate Shastri Bhawan by the end of September to pave the way for its demolition and redevelopment, the report added.
During the hearing, amicus curiae Senior Advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan told the court that efforts were being made to expedite the shifting of the books by November, although the Centre's affidavit had not been placed on record. She urged the court to stop the move and sought greater clarity from the Centre on the space available at the proposed new location, seeking a breakup of how much space is presently used for bookshelves compared with the new place. She also raised concerns about some books kept at RK Puram, saying she had visited the site and found them in "atrocious condition"; according to her, the books had remained in that state for the past 15 years and were part of the library's original collection.
The court then questioned the Additional Solicitor General about the urgency of shifting the books and directed the Centre not to move them. The order stated that the books would not be shifted until the next hearing, listed for 20 November, and that the affidavit filed on Monday would be placed on record.
