Karnataka minister Rizwan Arshad has urged the Centre to let motorists choose lower-ethanol E10 and ethanol-free petrol alongside E20, set up third-party fuel testing and create a compensation fund for vehicles damaged by excess blending. In a letter to Union petroleum minister Hardeep Singh Puri, he sought an "urgent course correction" in the E20 policy, citing state test results that found ethanol concentrations as high as 31.2% in petrol.
Arshad placed before the Union government the findings of statewide fuel quality and quantity inspections, underlining that Karnataka was not opposed to the Ethanol Blending Programme but to the alleged over-blending. There was no immediate reaction from the petroleum ministry on the letter. In the six-page letter, the minister said the programme "cannot come at the cost of the citizens" and that the issue was not ethanol blending per se but the manner of its implementation, particularly when prescribed limits were not being adhered to.
The letter follows a controversy after the Karnataka government collected petrol samples from fuel outlets across the state and sent them to National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL)-accredited labs. Of the 14 samples tested, 11 contained ethanol above the prescribed 20% limit, with concentrations ranging from 13.5% to 31.2%. Oil marketing companies have disputed the findings, questioning the sample-collection procedure adopted by state officials; Karnataka has rejected these objections, with the minister stating that officials followed procedures under the law.
Arshad also flagged discrepancies in fuel quantity dispensed during a statewide survey by Karnataka's Department of Legal Metrology, saying nearly 90% of the 805 retail outlets tested showed discrepancies. He argued that consumers should not be compelled to buy E20 when a substantial portion of the country's vehicle fleet may not be compatible with higher blends. The letter listed five demands, including mandatory disclosure of ethanol concentration at fuel stations, mention of the blend on customer receipts, random testing through NABL-accredited laboratories, a dedicated compensation fund for motorists whose vehicles are damaged by petrol containing ethanol above the prescribed limit, and the option to buy E10 and ethanol-free petrol along with E20 until all vehicles are fully compliant with higher blends.
