India has begun imposing an effective duty of 162.5% on bulk Scotch imports, exceeding the 150% charged before the India-UK trade agreement, according to eight sources and a government document. The pact, implemented in July, had halved tariffs on Scotch to 75%, a move welcomed by businesses and Britain as a major gain for companies such as Pernod Ricard and Diageo, which import Scotch in bulk and blend it for India's $65 billion liquor market.
In the first major dispute linked to the India-UK pact, Indian investigators have argued that companies are using incorrect customs classifications for bulk Scotch concentrates, which are treated as raw material for drinks such as blended whiskies. Since May, investigators say, such imports fall under a newly created customs line for "compound alcoholic preparations", attracting a 150% tariff, with a consumption tax taking the total duty to 162.5%, according to the government document and the sources. Thousands of litres of bulk Scotch in more than 80 shipping containers belonging to Pernod, Diageo and Bacardi have been stuck at ports, Reuters reported last week. Under a provisional release pending investigation, duty at 75% of the goods' value must be paid up front, with the rest covered by bank guarantees, the sources said.
Pernod, which owns UK-based Chivas Brothers, Diageo and many other Indian companies believe Scotch imports, both bulk and bottled, should be taxed only at 75% as per the trade pact. The British government has repeatedly said it is working with New Delhi on the issue, while India has said the dispute will be resolved soon. Pernod and Diageo have moved to arrange bank guarantees and other funding to get their blocked containers released, while Bacardi is still deciding its next steps, according to three of the sources. Diageo declined to comment, while Pernod and Bacardi did not respond to queries. The Indian finance ministry and the tax authority also did not respond.
Mumbai-listed majors Radico Khaitan, Allied Blenders and Distillers and Tilaknagar Industries all import bulk Scotch and are under scrutiny, like Pernod and Diageo. Smaller companies can face more stress in arranging bank guarantees as they may require collateral, and such guarantees also need to be reported as contingent liabilities. About 80% of Scotch whisky imports from Britain by volume arrive in bulk, and India is the biggest market for Scotch by volume. Most bulk Scotch imports go into making Indian-Made Foreign Liquor whisky by mixing a little Scotch with other spirits. A confidential memo from Indian investigators reported by Reuters last week said any misclassification under the India-UK pact needs to stop as it has "substantial revenue implications" for New Delhi. Industry sources said they did not anticipate the imposition of the additional local tax, with one describing it as "a googly".
