The Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court that there is no statutory requirement that only women personnel must handle women during crowd-control operations. The submission came in an affidavit responding to petitions alleging that male officers manhandled women protesters and journalists during protests seeking the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.

The petitions were filed by the Network of Women in Media, India, through advocate Aarthi Rajan, along with the Delhi Union of Journalists, Free Speech Collective and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists. The police said the legal provision requiring women officers for arrests and searches of women does not apply to crowd control in the same way. Deployment of women personnel in such situations is an operational consideration, depending on factors such as maintaining propriety, avoiding confrontation and defusing tensions, particularly when women are among the participants.

The police also said the mere presence of male personnel in crowd control cannot be treated as misconduct, and that there is no legal bar on a male officer acting as a first responder or assisting a woman officer. Such decisions, the affidavit said, have to be taken in a fraction of a second. It further stated that an October 11 Supreme Court direction asking the police not to hinder journalists, lawyers and other professionals did not extend to reel-makers, social media influencers or elements breaking lawful directions at a prohibited assembly.

The police said it fully respects the role of the press, but that some individuals were posing as journalists with cameras and microphones, and the protest site was crowded with content creators for YouTube. It said existing laws do not treat reel-makers or content creators as working journalists, and that this lack of a clear legal distinction hampered policing, especially during an unauthorised protest in July against question paper leaks in NEET-UG 2026, when thousands marched to Parliament.