A consumer commission in Chandigarh has ruled in favour of a man whose newly purchased jacket developed a tear under the arm within 46 minutes of being worn, according to a report by The Indian Express. The commission directed the retail store to pay ₹31,000 to the customer, who it said had been refused help. The order was reportedly passed on November 4.
The commission, comprising president Amrinder Singh Sidhu and member Brij Mohan Sharma, held that the store had failed to establish that the damage was caused by the customer's mishandling. It observed that the retailer had neither explained the basis of its findings nor submitted technical evidence, and had not conducted an independent inspection or obtained expert opinion in the matter. The store could not rely solely on its internal assessment to reject the complaint, the commission said, adding that the principle of "Buyer Beware" does not apply to consumers because the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 is a benevolent and welfare Act.
According to the report, the customer purchased three jackets from a store at a Chandigarh mall on December 25, 2025, one of which cost ₹10,999. He wore the disputed jacket for the first time on January 1, 2026, and reportedly noticed a small tear within 46 minutes. He emailed the store on January 10 seeking help and submitted the requested details and documents the following day. The retailer initially said the complaint had been escalated for review on January 12, but rejected the claim two days later, allegedly stating that the damage was caused by the customer's actions rather than a manufacturing defect.
The store maintained that the customer had been allowed to inspect and try on the jacket at the time of purchase, and that he had initially sought repairs, presenting that the damage occurred from his end. The commission rejected the claim, pointing out that the tear was located underneath the arm, in a relatively inconspicuous area that would not have been detected during checking. It held the store guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practice, directing it to refund ₹11,000 towards the jacket and pay an additional ₹20,000 as compensation for harassment and litigation expenses.
